Catalli Insurance Brokers

Catalli Insurance has been a part of the community since 1960. Our mission is to provide a broad range of insurance products that meet the varied needs of our customers. Prompt, accurate and professional advice along with fair prices and quality service delivered by insurance professionals is our goal and hallmark. The companies we represent are carefully selected to insure they share these values. Let us check your exposures, review your coverages and make recommendations where they’re needed. It’s all about securing your peace of mind and knowing that you are properly insured.

We will help you find the right combination of tailored, personalized insurance coverage at just the right price to fit your needs.

Insurance Tailored For You

We invite you to complete an online quote, call us at 650-349-1803, or contact us at [email protected] to review coverage options for car insurance, home insurance, life insurance, business insurance, renters insurance, boat insurance, and more. We provide free, no hassle and no obligation insurance quotes to help you make an informed insurance decision.

Affordable, Reliable Insurance Choices

Catalli Insurance Brokers strives to offer you quality insurance coverage, a high level of professional service and a long-term relationship. As independent insurance agents in San Mateo, well research rates and coverage from top insurance companies to find the best insurance rates and insurance plans for you. We do the insurance shopping and comparing for you to save you time and money!

Contact us or request a quote online today!.


The founder, Anthony J. Catalli, established Catalli Insurance in 1960, as a service oriented Insurance agency operating out of the home. His roots in the insurance industry began in his 20's working for brokerage houses in San Francisco. He was raised knowing the true meaning of hard work and the agency today is rooted in those principles and values. In 1974, Anthony's oldest son Paul was licensed as an insurance agent and in 1978 another son, Peter, joined the team. In 2000, they incorporated to form what is now Catalli Insurance, Inc. Now the 3rd generation is represented with grandson, Tony, who joined the business in 2008. We are all proud to be part of a legacy lasting over 50 years.

Established in 1960.


We specialize in Families with Young Drivers, Teachers, Scientists & Engineers, University Alumni, Civil Servants, and offer Good Driver Discounts. As "Independent Agents", we represent many different insurance companies, not just one. These companies offer comprehensive coverage's for most Business and Personal Insurance needs. We only work with companies that carry strong values, hold high financial ratings, and have competitive rates. Some of our major companies include: Mercury Insurance Group, Progressive Insurance, CSE insurance Group, Foremost Insurance Group, Hagerty Insurance, GeoVera Insurance, Pacific Select Property Insurance, Arrowhead Insurance, State Compensation Insurance Fund, and many more.